Share
A cold tub of ice cream arriving at your doorstep seems like a simple, straightforward order. But a recent video showing a rat in an ice-cream freezer at a Blinkit outlet has raised many questions around hygiene and food safety: if something goes wrong at the storage stage, how do you know whether the ice cream you have ordered is still safe to eat? Can a sealed pack still be safe?
The answer is not as simple as treating every product in the freezer as spoiled or contaminated. According to Dr Sanjay Indani, Director-Technical, ASK SafeFoodz Solutions Pvt Ltd, Navi Mumbai, the actual risk relies on factors such as whether the pest came into contact with the product, whether its packaging was compromised and if there was any further contamination.
Dr Idnani also shares simple checks consumers can follow to keep their delivered ice cream safe.
Does A Pest Incident Make Every Ice Cream In The Freezer Unsafe?
Surprisingly. Not necessarily. This is where the difference between a food-safety setback and actual product contamination becomes essential.
According to Dr Indani, a rat in an ice-cream freezer means a serious negligence of basic hygiene and pest-control standards, but it does not automatically mean that every sealed ice-cream pack within has been contaminated.
The first thing to confirm is whether the pest has come in contact with any products, whether packs were damaged and whether the surrounding freezer surfaces or other products have been affected. A totally sealed individual package delivers a barrier between the food and its outer environment.
That does not mean the incident should be overlooked, of course. The affected stock should be isolated and evaluated based on the actual contamination risk rather than automatically presuming that every product is either safe or simply unsafe.
(Image credit: Freepik)
What Actually Determines The Risk?
For consumers, there are two different things to consider: contamination and temperature.
A damaged, punctured, gnawed or leaking package can raise the risk of direct contamination. A pack that stays properly sealed presents a different situation.
Temperature is a different issue. Ice cream is a frozen product and, as per Dr Indani, should be maintained at around -18°C or below throughout the storage, transportation and delivery phase. At these temperatures, microbial growth does not spread further.
However, freezing does not necessarily destroy the microorganisms. It simply prevents their growth and further multiplication. This is why maintaining the cold chain is important even when the product looks perfectly okay.
What Happens If Ice Cream Melts And Refreezes?
This is one of the most useful situations for anyone who orders frozen food online.
When temperature fluctuations cause ice cream to melt and refreeze, it could pose a few risks. The first hint may be quality instead of an obvious safety alert: larger ice crystals, a change in texture or an altered taste.
But significant temperature misuse can also become a food-safety concern relying on the product and how long it has been exposed to inappropriate temperatures. This is why a consumer should not just assume that an ice cream is good because it has become solid again after being refrozen.
What Should You Check When The Delivery Arrives?
This is where consumers can actually do something about the situation. Instead of attempting to check what happened inside the retailer's freezer, check the product that has been delivered to you, adds Dr. Indani
Begin with the packaging. The seal should be unbroken, with no punctures, gnaw marks, cracks, leakage or other visible deterioration. Then check the date, expiry or best-before information, which should be valid and clearly mentioned and visible on the pack.
(Image credit: Freepik)
Next, check the frozen state. The ice cream should come properly frozen. Obvious melting, leakage or signs that the product has melted and refrozen are grounds to question the product rather than just putting it back in your freezer, assuming the heat has done it.
Finally, once the package is opened, look at its appearance and smell. If something seems clearly abnormal, do not consume it. Rather, report the issue to the quick-commerce platform or the manufacturer.
So, Should You Stop Ordering Ice Cream Online?
Dr Idnani says just a single isolated incident should not be considered the whole story. He stresses that consumers should stay vigilant without being unnecessarily alarmed about the entire frozen-food category
The larger lesson is that food safety does not rely on one checkpoint. Manufacturers, retailers, quick-commerce platforms and consumers all have a role in preserving the chain from production to consumption. A risk-based method means determining the hazard, assessing whether the product was actually exposed and then taking proper action.
For consumers, the advice is very simple: buy from trusted brands, check the date, review the pack and make sure the ice cream is appropriately frozen when it arrives.
