Share
If Earl Grey has only ever shown up in your cup, Christmas is a good time to let it do a little more work. Earl Grey is a flavoured black tea made by adding bergamot oil, extracted from the peel of a citrus fruit, to black tea leaves. The base tea can vary, often Assam or Ceylon, but the defining feature is always that citrus note sitting over a firm tea backbone. It is this balance that makes Earl Grey useful in the kitchen, not just pleasant to drink. The tea takes its name from Charles Grey, the 2nd Earl Grey, and has been widely consumed since the nineteenth century. Over time, cooks realised that it behaved particularly well with dairy, sugar, eggs, chocolate, and alcohol. In practical terms, that means it works with many of the ingredients already present on a Christmas table, it just needs to be used with a light hand. If you are planning a menu or just looking to add one unexpected element to your spread, these ideas are a good place to start.
1. Earl Grey Crème Brûlée
Crème brûlée is a baked custard made with cream, egg yolks, and sugar, finished with a caramelised sugar crust. It is a dependable dessert, which is exactly why it works well as a base for infusion. There is enough richness to carry flavour, but not so much complexity that additions get lost. To make an Earl Grey version, cream is warmed and steeped with loose-leaf tea, then strained before being mixed with egg yolks, sugar, and vanilla. The custard is baked slowly in a water bath until just set, chilled well, and finished with caramelised sugar just before serving. The method stays the same. Only the infusion changes. The slight bitterness from Earl Grey keeps the custard from feeling too heavy, and the citrus note stops the sugar crust from tasting sharp. If you already make crème brûlée for Christmas, this is an easy switch that adds an element of complexity.
2. Earl Grey Shortbread With Orange Zest
Shortbread is one of those Christmas staples that rarely needs improvement, but it does take well to small adjustments. Because it is made with butter, flour, and sugar, it is a good canvas for dry flavourings. Here, Earl Grey tea leaves are finely ground and mixed directly into the dough along with orange zest. The butter is creamed with sugar, flour is added, and the dough is shaped and baked until firm but pale. The biscuits should not brown deeply, as that dulls the tea flavour. Earl Grey works because butter carries its aroma evenly, while the low sugar content keeps the bitterness noticeable. The orange zest reinforces what is already in the tea rather than adding a separate flavour. These biscuits are easy to batch, store well, and make sense as gifts, which is exactly what you want during the festive season.
Image credit: Adobe Stock
3. Earl Grey Poached Pears
Poached pears are straightforward and adaptable, which makes them useful during busy Christmas cooking. They are made by simmering peeled pears gently in a flavoured liquid until tender. In this version, the liquid is a strong Earl Grey infusion, lightly sweetened, with citrus peel and vanilla added. The pears are cooked slowly and then left in the liquid as they cool, allowing them to absorb more flavour without falling apart. Using Earl Grey instead of heavier syrups keeps the dessert lighter and easier to place on a menu that already includes rich mains. The tea adds structure and bitterness, while the citrus keeps the fruit tasting fresh. This is a good option when you want dessert to feel indulgent without adding another heavy element to the table.
Image credit: Pexels
4. Earl Grey Milk Punch (Alcoholic Or Non-Alcoholic)
Milk punch is a drink that sounds a bit odd but is surprisingly practical once you understand it. The idea is simple: a flavoured liquid is clarified using milk and citrus, resulting in a clear, smooth drink that can be made ahead. Strong Earl Grey tea is mixed with sugar and citrus juice. Warm milk is added, causing curdling. The mixture is strained slowly until clear. Alcohol such as whisky or rum can be added, but the process works just as well without it. Earl Grey gives the drink definition. Without it, milk punch can lean too sweet or flat. The tea adds bitterness and aroma, meaning you do not need to keep adding flavours to make it interesting. This is a good make-ahead option if you are hosting and want something festive without last-minute effort.
Image credit: Adobe Stock
5. Earl Grey Chocolate Truffles
Chocolate truffles are small, rich, and usually served in moderation, which makes them ideal for subtle flavouring. The base is a ganache made from cream and chocolate. For an Earl Grey version, cream is infused with tea before being strained and combined with dark chocolate. Once the ganache sets, it is shaped and coated with cocoa powder or finely crushed tea leaves. Dark chocolate works best here because it has enough bitterness to stand up to the tea. Earl Grey sharpens the flavour rather than sweetening it, which keeps the truffle from tasting heavy. These work well as after-dinner bites or as part of a Christmas gift box.
Image credit: Pexels
6. Earl Grey Hot Toddy
A hot toddy is a warm drink made with a liquid base, sweetener, and citrus, often served in the evening. It is quick to assemble and meant to be consumed slowly. In this version, freshly brewed Earl Grey replaces plain hot water. Honey and lemon juice are added, and whisky can be included if desired. The drink is stirred gently and served hot. Earl Grey adds bitterness and aroma, which reduces the need for additional ingredients. The tea gives the drink shape and keeps it from tasting overly sweet. This is a good option for late evenings, especially when you want something warm without committing to a full cocktail.
Image credit: Pexels
